• 回复
  • 收藏
  • 点赞
  • 分享
  • 发新帖

趋肤效应的验证

最近和一个美国的工程师讨论了一下 趋肤效应, 他告诉我不用考虑趋肤效应对温升的影响,他们做过实验的, 请问有人做过此实验吗,结果怎样??

我贴上他的E-email供参考:
An experiment was performed to determine if skin effect is an issue.  The result was that skin effect is not an issue so the multi-strand wire will not help.( Note: the experiment was to measure temperature rise during actual operation with the actual high frequency waveforms and compare that to the temperature rise of the inductors with the same RMS value of DC current pumped through them with a DC power supply.   There was no significant difference in temperature rise that couldn’t be accounted for.)
全部回复(3)
正序查看
倒序查看
hlp330
LV.9
2
2009-07-07 17:24
我觉得这个实验有些缺陷
他是用高频交流电流和直流电流做比较的(且不考虑线径是否大于2倍的穿透深度),这两种电流对于磁芯的损耗都是不一样的,不具备可比性.
考不考虑趋肤效应,可以用多股线做下实验就知道了.
0
回复
ayong168
LV.5
3
2009-07-07 17:32
我是做大功率电源的,集肤效应把俺手指粗一根的铜棒都烧掉,把大铜棒换成多股线材搞定,还不要考虑温升?
0
回复
evdi
LV.6
4
2009-07-09 23:11
@ayong168
我是做大功率电源的,集肤效应把俺手指粗一根的铜棒都烧掉,把大铜棒换成多股线材搞定,还不要考虑温升?
应该是阻抗与阻值的区别.
0
回复